Sarsaparilla vs. Root Beer: What’s the Difference?

Many people are confused once the question of a difference between sarsaparilla vs. root beer arises. Considering their similarities, it is a logical question. Both of them are derived from the same root, and their appearance is pretty much the same. There are also many admirers of their taste worldwide. Plus, sarsaparilla is a necessary ingredient in both these beverages’ preparation.

Sarsaparilla vs. Root Beer What's the Difference 4

In the very beginning, both are made from the native North American plants’ roots and used as medicinal tonics. Manufacturers have used sarsaparilla vine to make sarsaparilla. On the other hand, now banned sassafras trees’ roots were the primary ingredient for producing root beer. Nowadays, many admirers agree that the differences between the two nowadays are minor. It is time to solve that mystery.

Sarsaparilla vs. Root Beer – History

The Native Americans used both beverages and named them after the ingredients they used in producing. They used sarsaparilla as a medicinal drink, but its naturally bitter taste was the probable reason for the root beer introduction.

At the very beginning, these two drinks were entirely different. Nowadays, root beer is also made from sarsaparilla with other ingredients added to indulge its bitter taste. That way, Americans got a sweet drink that they have loved for so long.

These two beverages have different tastes, but it is not all. They also differ in variations, alcohol percentage, and carbonation level. Plus, many people still consider the original sarsaparilla a medicinal drink that helps treat several health conditions.

There are also differences in preparation. To solve the issue of bitter sarsaparilla taste, people started to use licorice flavorings and wintergreen. As a result, they made a root beer variant that Charles Elmer Hires promoted as a brand.

What is Sarsaparilla?

What is Sarsaparilla
renegade brewing

Sarsaparilla (Zarzaparilla) is a soft drink initially produced from the sarsaparilla (zarzaparrilla) vine (Smilax ornata). This tuberous shaped plant without particular taste or smell originated in South America, Jamaica, Mexico, the Caribbean, West Indies, and Honduras.

Indigenous peoples of Central and South America used its roots for treating rheumatism, colds, cough, skin issues, but also in the prevention of sexual impotence and cancer. Spanish soldiers imported the plant to Europe in the 16th century as a cure for syphilis.

The beverage became popular in the US in the 19th century as a medicine for curing blood problems. It is possible to make this beverage with a few sarsaparilla species. It includes plants from the Smilax family or wild sarsaparilla belonging to the Aralia family.

It contains A, C, D, and B-complex vitamins and many minerals, including iron, iodine, manganese, copper, zinc, and silicon. Scientists have also discovered that this plant features active chemical properties, including anti-cancer and anti-inflammatory compounds and antioxidants:

  • Plant sterols – These plant sterols lower LDL cholesterol and decrease heart attack and stroke risk. Plus, they relieve arthritis pain by regulating interleukin-6 and modulating cortisol.
  • Flavonoids – These pigmentation chemicals boost the immune system thanks to their strong antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties. They also protect the body’s cells from damage caused by free radicals and inhibit LDL cholesterol oxidation.
  • Saponins – These glycosidic compounds lower total cholesterol, especially LDL. Plus, they enhance immune function and prevent the division of cancer cells thanks to their anti-mutagenic properties.

The beverage use is restricted for pregnant and nursing women and patients suffering from a sensitive stomach and kidney or prostate disorders.

What is Root Beer?

What is Root Beer
renegade brewing

Root beer is an essential part of American culture since the 19th century. The consumption started in the 1840s, but the first documented recipes dated to the 1860s.

Charles Elmer Hires was the one introducing Hires Root Beer as an alternative to alcohol in 1875. It was the first root beer commercial brand. His idea was to name the product Root Tea, but the ‘Root Beer’ label made it more attractive to coal miners in Pennsylvania.

Nowadays, manufacturers use different mixes to get unique flavors of this sweet and foamy drink. They produce different beverage types, including:

This drink’s primary ingredient was the sassafras (Sassafras albidum) from the laurel family. Unfortunately, it was discovered that volatile oils in this plant could cause cancer.

Since 90% of the tree is safrole, the FDA banned the plant use after uncovered its carcinogen properties. Nowadays, manufacturers flavor the modern beverage variation with sassafras oils and birch without adding the original plant. Most modern root beers don’t contain the sassafras but include:

  • Artificial flavors
  • Sweeteners like honey, aspartame, maple syrup, corn syrup, sugar, and molasses
  • Preservative sodium benzoate

This drink often contains a tasty combination of sarsaparilla roots and ingredients like cinnamon, vanilla, nutmeg, anise, honey, juniper, aspartame, burdock, and wintergreen. That is a reason why some experts consider it adulterated sarsaparilla.

Believe it or not, there is also a variation with added caffeine. These ingredients change the beverage taste, which is an excellent choice for people disliking original sarsaparilla bitterness. Most root beer production is centered in America, but you can also find some versions in Thailand and the Philippines. You can make your own beverage at home, as well.

The process of root beer production

The process of root beer production
renegade brewing

You should start by boiling molasses syrup and water. Then, cool it down for three hours before adding yeast, sassafras oil, and wintergreen.

After the fermentation process that lasts approximately 12 hours, you can strain and rebottle your beverage to allow the second fermentation. In most cases, you should stop the procedure once your root beer reaches 2% of alcohol. Any additional fermentation will cause an increased alcohol content level.

BBQ sauce recipe with root beer

Nowadays, you can use root beer to make an excellent tasty BBQ sauce. Ingredients include:

  • Root beer
  • Dark brown sugar
  • Mild-flavored molasses
  • Freshly squeezed lemon and orange juice
  • Grated lemon peel
  • Ground ginger
  • Garlic powder
  • Onion powder
  • Ketchup
  • Worcestershire sauce
  • Pepper and salt

Sarsaparilla vs. Root Beer: What’s the Difference?

Sarsaparilla vs. root beer (Chart)

Differences

Sarsaparilla

Root beer

Definition

Beverage derived from zarzaparrilla plantBeverage derived from sassafras plant

History

Native Americans used it as a medicinal drinkCharles Elmer Hires established it as a commercial drink in 1875

Ingredients

Sarsaparilla vineSarsaparilla plant combined with cinnamon, vanilla, nutmeg, anise, honey, aspartame, and wintergreen

Flavor

Unique, bitter, bolder aftertasteSweet, foamy, lighter aftertaste that depends on the ingredients used

Form

It is a non-alcoholic beverageIt can be a carbonated or non-carbonated and alcoholic or non-alcoholic beverage

Medical concerns

Anti-inflammatory agent and antioxidantContained cancer-causing oil extract before the change in the production process

Both sarsaparilla and root beer are popular drinks that the Native Americans made before Europeans arrived at the new continent. In the beginning, they use these beverages as tonics to cure some medical conditions. However, there are a few primary differences between the two, such as:

Ingredients

Initially, people used the sarsaparilla vine to produce sarsaparilla. On the other hand, root beer was made from the sassafras tree’s roots and bark and birch oil. As I have already mentioned, these roots are excluded from use because of potential carcinogenic properties.

There is also a difference in other ingredients’ content. Initially, sarsaparilla contains only the vine. However, manufacturers have mixed sarsaparilla plants with many different components over time to get various flavors.

Forms

Sarsaparilla is a carbonated soft drink, while you can find carbonated and non-carbonated root beer. While sarsaparilla is always a non-alcoholic beverage, you can choose to drink alcoholic or non-alcoholic root beer.

Color

The most popular sarsaparilla color is soft and gentle brown, while root beer is more dark brown.

Taste

Sarsaparilla is well-known for its bolder and pretty bitter taste. Nowadays, some manufacturers add licorice or some other sweeter ingredients to reduce the bitterness. On the other hand, root beer is sweet with a lighter aftertaste. It significantly differs in flavors, depending on added ingredients.

More Popular Drink in the US – Sarsaparilla vs. Root Beer

More Popular Drink in the US - Sarsaparilla vs. Root Beer
renegade brewing

The fact is that root beer is the most popular beverage in the US and makes approximately 3% of the country’s all-available soft drink market. However, variations in consumer taste and looking for healthier options have affected both beverages’ recipes over the years.

The latest market research shows that full-calorie sodas consumption has declined by more than 25% in recent years, and most Americans try to avoid soft drinks. Statistically, teens drunk such beverages about 24% less in 2013 compared to 2006. As a result, childhood obesity has decreased over the previous seven years.

That affects the sarsaparilla and root beer production, as well. Nowadays, companies substitute corn syrup with cane sugar to get low-calorie drinks. The first positive results were shown very quickly. That means you can drink your favorite beverages and stay healthy and slim at the same time.

Conclusion

Both sarsaparilla and root beer are tasty and highly popular in the US. Which one will be your preferred choice is a matter of your taste. If you like a bit bitter flavor, you should pick out a glass of sarsaparilla. Otherwise, sweet root beer is the beverage for you.

One more thing! With sarsaparilla, you will get a non-alcoholic, healthy drink, while you can choose among a few sweet beer options. Whatever your decision is, cheers!

Sarsaparilla vs. Root Beer What's the Difference 3

1 thought on “Sarsaparilla vs. Root Beer: What’s the Difference?”

  1. This is an excellent source of information regarding my favorite soft-drink. I had no idea that there were so many varieties of root beer with different ingredients. I wish there were a place to taste all of them. Thank you for posting.

    Reply

Leave a Comment